In This Article
- Why megalodons have captured our imagination and what researchers have learned from their extinction
It is also possible that the megalodon was hunted by early humans, although there is little evidence to support this theory. This suggests that the megalodon’s extinction was not caused by a single event, but rather a combination of factors that affected different populations in different ways. This event caused significant changes to the ocean’s currents and temperature, which may have made it difficult for the megalodon to find food and mate. Upwelling and the Gulf Stream may have also played a role in the megalodon’s extinction.
- Scientists would expect a surviving population to show significant evolutionary changes reflecting adaptation to new ecological niches, particularly if they transitioned from warm, shallow waters to cold, deep-ocean environments.
- Extraordinary claims about megalodon survival would require extraordinary evidence, such as recent physical specimens, verifiable DNA, or unambiguous photographic/video documentation—none of which has been forthcoming despite modern technological capabilities.
- Fossil whale bones have been discovered bearing deep gouges and puncture marks that match Megalodon teeth.
- It is crucial to apply critical thinking and skepticism when evaluating claims of megalodon survival.
The 2017 study by Slater and colleagues links whale gigantism mainly to richer, seasonal upwelling of food along coasts. Pimiento and Clements noticed that the modern line-up of gigantic filter-feeding whales was established after megalodon’s extinction. Shark scientists criticised it, and the NHM describes it as full of faked photos, footage and sightings that were “swiftly debunked”. A shark weighing many tonnes could not survive in the dark, cold trenches people imagine it hiding in. Because sharks have skeletons made of cartilage, which usually rots away after death, says the Natural History Museum. See which animal has the strongest bite force for how it compares with measured bites.
Megalodon teeth are found in marine sediments dating back millions of years, but none have been discovered in geological layers younger than 3.6 million years old. Shark skeletons are made of cartilage rather than bone, which doesn’t fossilize easily. The fossil record provides the most compelling evidence that these animals are truly extinct. The behavior of this ancient species likely resembled that of modern great whites, but on a dramatically larger scale.
Why megalodons have captured our imagination and what researchers have learned from their extinction
Long-term changes in climate and ocean conditions, shifts in prey availability, and ecological competition are commonly considered together when explaining the decline and disappearance of large marine predators. Some researchers vampire squid have proposed that large marine predators used coastal areas as nursery habitats for juveniles, a pattern seen in several modern sharks. Without direct observation, researchers evaluate likelihood using comparative data from living predators and the fossil record. This ecological logic, combined with tooth form and fossil evidence showing interactions with marine mammals, supports the interpretation that megalodon fed on large prey.
There are similarities in tooth shape, and fossil bite marks on similar species also suggest that the white sharks may have outcompeted megalodon, or outcompeted juvenile megalodon. It’s very likely that the megalodon was a true apex predator, not targeted as prey by any other marine animal. To be in such a high position they may have been eating now-extinct marine mammals, such as predatory sperm whales. In our studies, we used nitrogen and zinc isotopes to reconstruct the diets of sharks. The zinc isotope method is also new; this study marks the first time it has been applied to sharks and fossils more than 86,000 years old.
The absence of contemporary evidence such as the sightings of carcasses, modern fossil records, or credible video footage reinforces the consensus that Megalodon is indeed extinct. Scientists believed this impacted large marine mammals as well as fish and other smaller organisms that could not cope with the colder temperatures. The earliest known fossils date to 20 million years ago and it’s currently thought that megalodon went extinct around 3.6 million years ago. If estimates are correct, megalodon had a bite force three times that of Tyrannosaurus rex and a whopping 10 times that of a great white shark! Just one reasonably preserved megalodon vertebral column exists, and it’s the size of a dinner plate! This gigantic shark with fearsome jaws certainly was real, but it went extinct long before humans walked the earth.
The extinction of megalodon had a positive impact on other apex predators of the time, such as the great white shark, in some cases spreading to regions where megalodon became absent. Megalodon were contemporaneous with whale-eating toothed whales (particularly macroraptorial sperm whales and squalodontidae), which were also probably among the era's apex predators, and provided competition. Among several specimens found in the Gatún Formation of Panama, one upper lateral tooth was used by other researchers to obtain a total length estimate of 17.9 meters (59 ft) using this method.
Estimated length and weight
The climate-driven changes led directly to a cascade of ecological problems, affecting the Megalodon’s food chain and competitive landscape. This period saw the planet enter a phase of cooling, leading toward the eventual onset of major ice ages. Paleontologists have long sought to understand how such a successful apex predator vanished from the fossil record. Its immense size, with estimated lengths reaching 60 feet, allowed it to thrive across marine ecosystems during the Miocene and Pliocene epochs.
"Its disappearance had cascading consequences. Whales, one of their key prey items, got even bigger after megalodon went extinct with nothing around to eat them," he added. Megalodon (left tooth) may have been driven to extinction, in part, by the arrival of great white sharks (right tooth). Firstly, the food chain would look very different if the species was still alive. "Any suggestion that megalodon potentially still exists in unexplored ocean regions is complete nonsense based on not a shred of credible evidence," he told Live Science in an email. He has spent years studying the megalodon — and says they are most definitely extinct.
But Sternes said those studies relied on assumptions about similarities between only the two shark species. The study helps confirm the hypothesis that the megalodon was not “merely a gigantic version of the modern-day great white shark,” as previously thought, said Phillip Sternes, an educator at SeaWorld San Diego and a researcher on the project. The monster shark, depicted in the 2018 sci-fi horror film "The Meg," was previously believed to be between 50 and 65 feet long.